top of page

In My Feelings Right Now - A Review of "28 Summers" by Elin Hilderbrand

Aug 6, 2020
6 min read

Updated: Oct 25, 2020

SPOILER ALERT: I will be talking about the whole book in this review. If you don't want to know, stop reading now.

Elin Hilderbrand's newest book, "28 Summers".

Many, many years ago I discovered Elin Hilderbrand. I think the first book I read of hers was "A Summer Affair". I was so excited to see that she had others -- and I devoured them. From that moment, I was a Elin Hilderbrand superfan. Her books usually come out in the summer, so it became a tradition for me to buy her book the day it was available and save it to read while we are in Maine.

This year I had the opportunity to "meet" Elin at Broweseabout Books in Rehoboth. Despite COVID-19, she made a few in-person appearances. I bought a ticket and spent my days of quarantine looking forward to an evening trip to the beach -- and praying the event didn't get cancelled. I knew I wouldn't really get to meet Elin, but at least I would get a signed copy of the new novel and maybe wave to her from a safe distance.

Broweseabout did a great job of organizing the event. They divided us into timed groups, allowed us to peruse the closed store while we waited, and gave us each a gift certificate to use while there. Elin was in the entryway of another room, about 10' back from her fans. When it was our turn, we each held up a card with our name on it so she could sign the book, she took a picture with us (her adorable boyfriend did the honors), we waved and tried to breathe in some of her magic....and then we were on our way. I cannot even explain how much I love a brand-new book -- but having one signed by EH herself???? Priceless.

Amazingly, I held off on diving into the novel because I was planning on keeping with tradition: reading it in Maine by the pool. Our vacation was still a "go" for mid-July.

And then, we weren't going to Maine because, well, COVID-19 sucks.

To say that I was heartbroken is an understatement. It took quite a while for that sting to subside. Even though I knew I was now free to start my book, there was no way I could read about an idyllic summer destination that reminded me so much of my favorite summer place.

Oh my. Why, why, why did I wait? Tonight when I finished it (all 417 pages), I just sat in my feelings. It was A LOT to handle. Honestly, at about page 415 I literally almost threw the book against the wall. One, I wasn't ready for it to end. Two, I wasn't ready to lose Mallory Blessing. Three, it hit (almost) all of my fears.

It took me a LONG time to finish it (mainly because I get distracted every other page by a needy family member), but I am glad it did. Reading an EH book is like enjoying a really, really good box of Godiva chocolates with some expensive red wine. You want to savor every moment, but you tend to rush because you just can't help yourself.

So yes, this book lived in my head for a few weeks. The premise? A young woman meets an unavailable guy, they have chemistry but no real desire or capability to make a commitment, they agree to see each other one weekend every year no matter what, they both go about their regular lives and time rolls on -- but they always honor their "same time, next year" pact. Always. For 28 years.

And then Mallory dies.

Gut-wrenching. But here were some of my thoughts on this book (possibly my most favorite book ever):

1. Mallory Blessing is a real main character, flaws and all.

It's pretty ballsy to have your protagonist be an adulteress -- an ongoing one, at that. But EH did it brilliantly. Throughout the book I thought to myself, "I shouldn't be rooting for her and Jake. This is wrong. So wrong." But yet, I loved Mallory for who she was: imperfect but incredibly likeable. She had guilt. She had remorse. But she also had self-awareness. She knew that her relationship with Jake probably couldn't sustain life outside their Nantucket bubble. So she enjoyed what they had. She didn't dwell on jealousy or "what if" scenarios. She dated and had a baby and maintained friendships and was a respected high school English teacher (you know I loved that). She lived her life. She understood real love, but she accepted that she couldn't completelty have the man she wanted. The best part about her was how flawed she was: one night stands, lapses in judgment, allowing her BFF to treat her like shit, uncharitable thoughts about her parents, drunken nights, adultery, immature revenge. She was a real person. And by the end, I absolutely LOVED Mallory Blessing.

2. A book that spans 28 years makes you realize that time goes by so fast.

This was a big book, but it felt so much bigger because you traveled through time with these characters. You witnessed normal events that occur when you are following someone for almost 3 decades: weddings, divorces, births, deaths, job changes, perspective shifts. And the ultimate mark of time passing? The end of summer. As EH took us through the years (from 1993 to 2020), each chapter started with the highlights of that year. I Ioved going down memory lane, remembering news stories and pop culture and books and music. More than once I thought to myself, "That happened that long ago? It seemed like just last year." It gave the reader a distinct feeling of time passing...which is a sobering thought for all of us. (Side Note: so very glad that Bradley Cooper made the 2019 opening - she mentioned two of his movies during other years: American Sniper and The Hangover, but was happy he finally got mentioned...even if it was with Lady Gaga).

3. My biggest fears were addressed in this book.

There were a few points in this one that I almost stopped reading. It was too hard. When Mallory and Cooper's parents were killed in a random highway accident, my heart jumped. I fear every day about something like that happening to my parents or my husband and kids. It is a weird anxiety that I have to overcome daily. Then the cancer came. And not any cancer: skin cancer. Don't get me wrong...I am scared of all things cancer. But whenever someone mentions melanoma, I silently freak. And the fact that Mallory had to leave behind a 19-year-old son? Heartbreaking.

4. Let's talk about that mother-son relationship.

Oh boy. Literally. Watching Link and Mallory grow together through the years was bittersweet. From him being a happy little boy to being a somewhat-difficult teen, the connection between the two of them was touching. Personally, I loved reading about Link's summer travel ball adventures -- including his inability to get a hit (currently, I can relate to that one -- it's hard to watch your kid struggle). My first tears started to fall at page 393 when Link was a senior in high school. Mallory was at his last home baseball game and rememberd back to the early days of travel ball; at the time, she didn't realize how fast time would pass. As a mom who is in the midst of travel ball with a 10-year-old boy, it hit me HARD: I need to enjoy these moments because very soon -- too soon -- my little boy will be leaving me. The final blow was when Mallory remembered her late father playing baseball with his one-year-old grandson -- her dad is now gone and her boy is grown. TOO. MUCH. (Confession: I am bawling my eyes out now as I write).

It's no secret that the real reason I love EH (besides her life on Nantucket) is that I want to be able to write just like her: smart, witty, current, and realistic. Every time I think, "Eh, I'm sure this one won't be as good" -- she blows me away. This book will have a special place on my forever bookshelf.

Elin at Broweseabout Books in June with my signed copy. (I cropped myself out, but you can see my elbow)

 
 
 

Comments


  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn

©2018 by The Practical Dreamer. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page